Column „Wenn’s recht ist“ · Civil and employment law · 05/2023

Secretly recording a conversation: can I use the recording?

Mag. Nevena Shotekova-Zöchling – attorney at law in Vienna

Your co-pilot in litigation

Mag. Nevena Shotekova-Zöchling

Attorney at law in Vienna · 16 years of legal practice · Civil & employment law

You stay at the controls and make the decisions. We sit next to you in the cockpit, know the route and the instruments – and when it gets turbulent, we take over.

Column „Wenn’s recht ist“ by Mag. Nevena Shotekova-Zöchling – an English translation of the column originally published in German in Austromatisierung 05/2023. The text reflects the law as it stood at the time of first publication. Original (German, PDF)

Recording one's own conversations or conversations between third parties is, in principle, prohibited and punishable. According to established case law, the audio recording of a face-to-face conversation or a telephone call without the consent of the other party is also generally unlawful. Such a recording should therefore only be considered if it appears indispensable for one's own defence in proceedings.

In some individual cases, for example to secure evidence (Beweissicherung), a recording may exceptionally be justified, although the interests must always be weighed in the individual case. The recordings must never be published or used outside the proceedings and should be employed as the last suitable means. All other offers of evidence, such as witness statements, must be considered beforehand.

Systematic and covert video or conversation surveillance always constitutes a far-reaching infringement of rights, particularly since marital disputes or the taking of evidence in such disputes would rather be resolved by engaging a private detective. A systematic recording of marital arguments – if particularly far-reaching – may therefore well be impermissible. In many marital conflicts, observation by a detective would be more justified than video or conversation surveillance.

On the other hand, the legitimate interest of the person making the recording must always be weighed in the individual case:

  • The audio recording of a private business meeting without the consent of the other party is, in principle, unlawful.
  • However, submitting an exact transcript of a secret telephone or conversation recording in court proceedings is permissible without a balancing of interests.
  • Under § 120 StGB (Criminal Code, Strafgesetzbuch), making the audio recording accessible or publishing it is a criminal offence, but using a transcript of the recording is not.
  • Video recording of an official act, such as court enforcement (Exekution), for the purpose of securing evidence would be permissible. Any subsequent publication of the video, for instance on the video platform “YouTube”, would then be impermissible, unless there were a strong public interest in information (an imminent overstepping of the bailiff's powers).
  • Submitting chat logs (for instance from the messenger service “WhatsApp”) for evidential purposes is in principle also permissible, even if they should contain sensitive data.

In a recent decision of the Supreme Court (OGH 21. 4. 2023, 8 ObA 18/23i), the summary dismissal (Entlassung) of a secretary was upheld because she had left her mobile phone on her desk with the audio recording function activated in order to record a conversation between a member of the bank's management board and her superior in her absence. In the OGH's view, the employee's conduct in this case even constituted a criminal offence, as she had secretly recorded a conversation between third parties. Had she instead secretly recorded her own conversation with someone else, only passing on the recording would have been a criminal offence.

It is therefore advisable always to have any such intended conduct legally reviewed in advance and to consider its possible consequences.

Further reading

Employment lawSummary dismissal, termination and claims arising from employment.
Family lawDivorce, maintenance and custody – including the question of admissible evidence.
Drones over your propertyWhen aerial recordings violate your privacy.

Frequently asked questions

Is it permitted in Austria to record a conversation secretly?

In principle, no. According to established case law, recording a conversation without the consent of the other party is unlawful. Secretly recording conversations between third parties is a criminal offence under § 120 StGB.

Can I use a secret recording in court?

Only exceptionally, for example to secure evidence, after weighing the interests in the individual case and as a last resort. According to case law, submitting an exact transcript is permissible; publishing the audio recording itself or making it accessible is a criminal offence.

Can I submit WhatsApp chats as evidence?

In principle, yes, even if they contain sensitive data.

Can a secret recording at the workplace lead to summary dismissal?

Yes. The OGH upheld the summary dismissal of a secretary who had secretly recorded a conversation between a management board member and her superior (OGH 8 ObA 18/23i).

Column by Mag. Nevena Shotekova-Zöchling, attorney at law (Rechtsanwältin) in Vienna, published in Austromatisierung 05/2023. Law as at the time of first publication – general information, not legal advice in an individual case.

Do you need evidence – on legally safe ground?

We check in advance which evidence is admissible and represent you in the proceedings.

Send an enquiryGet in touch+43 1 34 601 71